Pity and Compassion

What is pity, and what is compassion?

I have always tried to make the people around me understand that pity is something deeply sinful. At first glance, this may sound strange – or, more precisely, counterintuitive, perhaps even selfish. But that is because one is not aware of all the consequences, let alone capable of grasping them in their entirety. All of this sets off many further chains of consequences and, above all, involves decisions invisibly bound up with one another.

Some experienced or wise people might say, “That’s real life.” Life simply involves entering terrain hidden in darkness. I am not talking here about situations that address the issue of security or safety – because there is no such thing in life. The only certain thing in life is death. Everything else is uncertain and unsure – and carries a great deal of responsibility. Above all, one should never overlook the invisible connections between things.

Many people think: What is wrong with suffering alongside someone? Isn’t that pity? Your pity is a drop in the ocean – more of a ritual, and really a kind of hypocrisy. For example: “Oh, look, that’s so sad.”

True pity means being aware of the consequences and accepting them in their entirety – unto eternity. It also means accompanying the person who is suffering until their suffering ends. The problem, however, is that each individual is made up of many connections. What I mean is that no one is truly without ties.

There may be foolish people who say, “I’ll go wherever you go, even into the severed-off part.” Is that love, or betrayal – or self-deception?

Do you know the consequences of Rama’s decision to take his wife with him into exile? If she had not gone with him, many events would never have taken place. But that is not what I mean. Besides, true love also means letting go.

You say, “I would give up my life for someone.” Yet that, too, sets off further consequences. A person in their limited state may never be aware of many of them.

Now you feel compassion for someone, and it turns out that your entire community is being dragged into the abyss along with them. This brings me to the question Draupadi asked her husbands:

“Did Yudhishthira lose himself first and then stake me, or did he stake me before he lost himself?“

In asking this, she challenges whether Yudhishthira still had the right to dispose of her after he had already gambled away his own freedom. She asks those present to decide whether this had lawfully made her a slave.

In the same way, everything in this world is interconnected – including your relationships.

Why is child marriage prohibited in modern states, for example in Western countries? Because children are considered not yet mature enough to make such decisions. Do you really believe you are adults? You, too, will be bound by the consequences of your decisions. As I’ve said before, in a divine sense, growing up means awakening from sleep. The wordplay is clearer in German, where Erwachsenwerden (“growing up”) echoes Erwachen (“awakening”). I am not referring to the etymological explanation of the term “growing up“.

Are you aware – are you truly awake enough – to make such decisions? If not, why don’t you lay everything down? And if you will never have the ability or potential to make these decisions, why do you make them anyway?

Some decisions extend across lifetimes (rebirths). Most people are unaware of this – especially those who refuse to accept ideas such as rebirths because they find them troubling to their own belief system.

The most important thing is to take action rather than just talk. If someone has lost their legs due to war, one should not simply look at them and express pity; instead, one should offer support – for instance, by accompanying them to the appropriate agency where they can be provided with a suitable prosthesis, or by helping them purchase one. Furthermore, if they are unable to work, one should help them identify appropriate opportunities and paths forward.